SCMAP Perspective is our fortnightly column on PortCalls, tackling the latest developments in the supply chain industry, as well as updates from within SCMAP. On this column, Henrik Batallones looks at how strong supply chains is also as much about ensuring the steady production of supply rather than just moving goods.
Securing the supply
LEGAZPI, ALBAY – Lately, I’ve been thinking about how we still tend to conflate “logistics” with all of “supply chain”.
Logistics, of course, is the act of physically moving any and all sorts of goods – raw materials, finished products, everything in between – and, arguably, as well as capital and people from one point to another. This is just one aspect of supply chain, which looks at how a business generates value for itself, its partners and its customers. Supply chain does not begin and end with the movement of products, but rather from planning your resources so you can deliver against current and future demand.
I’ve been thinking of all this as SCMAP embarks on another engagement with the Department of Trade and Industry. I am writing this from Legazpi, Albay, the main gateway to the Bicol region. We are here to visit stakeholders in the region’s coconut industry, as part of a project mapping the coconut oil supply chain, identifying gaps and making policy recommendations – although of course, we can’t help but also touch on other products that rely on coconuts, from food and beauty products to handicrafts. The coconut, after all, is a tree that keeps on giving.
But the Bicol region is, of course, quite prone to disasters. While it is a major hub for growing and processing coconuts, the region being on the path of strong typhoons means that often coconut trees have to be replanted. This is what I heard from farmers in Catanduanes, which has the lowest contribution to the coconut industry in the region; as one of the first places where Bicol-bound storms make landfall, it is difficult for coconut trees to mature and start bearing fruit. It takes around three years, one farmer said, but strong storms would always come and the counter pretty much restarts.
Incidentally, we met a lot of entrepreneurs from the island province still working with coconut despite these limitations. Ironically, they have to source their raw materials from elsewhere in Bicol, if not the rest of the country.
One challenge of the coconut industry in the Philippines is the low productivity of our trees. We may have a lot of them, but they yield considerably less compared to our Southeast Asian neighbors, particularly Indonesia. It is particularly felt now that we’re in the midst of a “super” El Niño, which is expected to last to the middle of next year, and by government estimations will bring drought-like conditions to most of the country. One cooperative leader told us that this means their coconut trees will yield even less, and existing fruit will get “burnt” before they fall to the ground, even before they get a chance to be harvested and converted to copra.
Coconut farmers here do not just rely on the tree completely. Intercropping – the practice of growing multiple crops in the same field to improve soil productivity and balance – means some also grow vegetables, cocoa or pili. The yields of those crops will obviously also be affected by the El Niño. I can only imagine what lies ahead for the people we have met over the last couple of weeks.
When we talk about supply chain, we also talk of securing the supply – not just by procuring the right amount of raw materials from the right partners at the right price. From a national perspective, this means ensuring that Filipinos are able to draw from our resources when they need it, whether to sustain themselves, or to generate value for others by processing them into value-adding products. There is a lot of talk among the stakeholders we have met on going beyond the manufacturing and selling of copra – perhaps there is a need to make the process of creating virgin coconut oil more efficient so farmers can feel it is worth the slightly higher selling price? But it all begins with making sure that, in this case, the crops themselves are productive, that the coconut trees and healthy and hardy, and that they can yield more of the fruit that delivers so much for Bicolandia, from the delicacies we eat to the home items we think of bringing home.
This is not necessarily a job that logistics can solve. “Supply chain” is sexy, sure, but it does not mean one cannot contribute if they don’t have an involvement in storage and transportation. I would like to see our government do more in addressing coconut farmers’ issues with the source, and from the source: eradicating the “cocolisap”, developing trees that can withstand typhoons, making sure that the yield per tree steadily improves.
With the increased yield, we can then look at further developing the coconut ecosystem – promoting investment in mills, for example, which allow farmers to sell oil instead of just copra. And then logistics can come in, to provide greater market access to these new products, generating more value to the many honest stakeholders we have met, and allowing them to contribute more meaningfully to their colleagues and to their communities.
